Who’re you calling a socialist? Republicans are the actual

Steven Strauss, Opinion columnist Printed 3:15 a.m. ET Dec. 18, 2020 | Up to date 2:04 p.m. ET Dec. 19, 2020

Republicans assault Democrats as socialists, however the insurance policies they assist present they’re the true socialists. Progressives ought to maintain them accountable.

With Senate management on the road in two Georgia runoff elections subsequent month, Republicans are claiming that President-elect Joe Biden and the Democrats are “socialists.” That’s their shorthand for presidency interference within the economic system, corruption, failure to implement the legislation, incompetence, and subsidizing individuals who ought to assist themselves.

Let me counsel 4 areas the place the incoming Biden administration, allied with severe conservatives, can battle “socialism” whereas upholding progressive values.   

► Get rid of farm subsidies and farm assist applications (which is able to price $46 billion this yr — up from $22 billion final yr — and can account for about 40% of this yr’s farm earnings) that intervene with agricultural markets. As Chris Edwards on the Cato Institute famous: “Agriculture is not any riskier than different industries and doesn’t want an array of federal subsidies.” Additionally from the Cato Institute: “About 97% of all farm households are wealthier than the median U.S. family. Farm earnings was 52% larger than median U.S. family earnings.”  

I do know of no progressive group that helps these farm subsidy applications.  Nevertheless, America’s farmers are completely different from different Individuals. They’re 95% white  and do one factor nearly all of Individuals refuse to do: Farmers overwhelmingly vote Republican (President Donald Trump might have gotten as a lot as 85% of the farm vote this yr). 

Tax subsidies that make no sense

► Get rid of the money-losing “socialist” Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program. From the viewpoint of progressives (who consider local weather change is an actual and urgent concern), NFIP is not sensible. It encourages dwelling in flood-prone areas (the place progressives consider flooding will worsen because of local weather change) by providing sponsored federal flood insurance coverage. Because the Basic Accounting Workplace famous: “NFIP premiums don’t replicate the total threat of loss, which will increase the Federal fiscal publicity created by this system, obscures that publicity from Congress and taxpayers …” 

In 2017, Congress wrote off $16 billion in losses from this program. However by March 2020, it had already collected one other $20 billion in losses. About 60% of NFIP insurance policies have been issued in Florida, Louisiana, and Texas, which all voted for Trump this yr. 

U.S. Capitol constructing on March 25, 2020, in Washington, D.C. (Photograph: Alex Edelman/AFP through Getty Pictures)

► Make investments $10 billion per yr to fund IRS tax enforcement, focused on the very rich — these making over $1 million a yr. In keeping with a latest estimate by former Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers, College of Pennsylvania legislation professor Natasha Sarin and former IRS Commissioner Charles O. Rossotti, this funding would yield about $100 billion a yr in further Federal tax revenues. 

Sen. Sherrod Brown: Firms exploit staff even amid COVID. They do not should run the economic system.

When you’re a conservative who thinks defunding police enforcement is a nasty concept, you need to suppose the identical about the latest defunding of IRS tax enforcement (by slicing the IRS finances). The IRS finances shrank 20% in actual phrases from 2010 to 2019, whereas in the identical interval the U.S. economic system grew about 25%. The result’s that the variety of audits of Individuals making over $1 million per yr declined by about 75%. On the similar time, the IRS was pressured to focus its scarce assets on auditing low earnings Individuals. Notably, the primary driver of this IRS defunding is the GOP. 

► Make states routinely sponsored by the remainder of the nation get their act collectively. Most American states are roughly in steadiness between what their residents pay into the federal authorities and what they obtain again. A number of states (primarily Democratic) are “maker” states (amongst them Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey and New York) that pay vastly extra to the federal authorities than they obtain. 

‘Taker’ states do unhealthy job for residents

Then there are states that get again much more than their residents pay in taxes. These “taker” states are primarily low-income states within the southeast, most of them dominated by Republicans. Given our progressive tax system and security web, federal cash tends to mechanically stream to those states.   

When you’re a conservative, transferring cash from “makers” to “takers” is usually frowned on. When you’re a progressive, it is smart to ask some laborious questions on what’s occurring with these “taker” states. As a result of, regardless of all the cash these states obtain, they don’t do a great job for his or her residents.   

Mississippi illustrates simply how unhealthy this example is. Yearly, Mississippi receives $19 billion extra from the federal authorities than it pays into the system. Regardless of this assist, Mississippi has the best murder fee, highest toddler mortality charges and lowest median family earnings of any American state. 

No socialist nightmare: Georgia, when you’re listening, ignore conservatives peddling socialist Senate hallucinations

It is time the leaders in these poorly run states make modifications to enhance the lives of their residents — hopefully whereas lowering their hefty dole from the remainder of the nation. If they’re unwilling to reform, possibly federal cash and applications ought to be lower off.

A few of what I’m proposing would require laws, and the satan’s within the particulars. However when you’re an ideological conservative, you ought to be prepared to work with the Biden administration to implement some or all of those proposals.

When you’re a hypocritical member of the GOP (that’s, you wish to hold utilizing federal tax {dollars} to purchase the farm vote for Republican candidates), and-or a Trumpist, you in all probability detest every thing I’ve proposed. Nevertheless it’s time for the incoming Biden administration to drag again the curtain on which is the true occasion of socialism in America. 

Steven Strauss is a lecturer and visiting professor on the Princeton College of Public and Worldwide Affairs and a member of USA TODAY’s Board of Contributors. Comply with him on Twitter: @Steven_Strauss


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Final SlideNext Slide

Learn or Share this story: https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2020/12/18/republicans-real-socialists-farmers-flood-insurance-defund-irs-column/3923878001/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *